Magnetic Motion
EnergyForces and InteractionsPhysicsMatter and its InteractionsEngineering Design

Magnetic Motion

Grades 3–8
1 hr 30 min
7 steps
NGSS

Standards Alignment

NGSS

  • 3-PS2-3: Ask questions to determine cause and effect relationships of electric or magnetic interactions between two objects not in contact with each other.
  • 3-PS2-4: Define a simple design problem that can be solved by applying scientific ideas about magnets.
  • MS-PS2-3: Ask questions about data to determine the factors that affect the strength of electric and magnetic forces.
  • 4-PS3-4: Apply scientific ideas to design, test, and refine a device that converts energy from one form to another.

Lesson Steps

1

Overview

Not listed

Welcome to the Magnetic Motion project! In this project, students will explore the interactions of magnets, electricity, and copper wires!

From your teacher, each student will collect 2, 8-inch pieces of wire and each group will need 1, 10-foot piece of wire. Groups will be given magnets, AAA Batteries, and AA Batteries, a button compass, a dowel, and pliers.

A note about safety. The magnets used in this project are high-strength neodymium magnets. This means that they can hurt you if used improperly. So to minimize the chance of any accidents, here are some rules to follow:

1. Do not let the magnets snap together. Sometimes parts of the magnets can chip off. Not only does that damage the magnet, but the chips could injure you! Make sure to bring the magnets together slowly when possible.

2. Don't put the magnet next to any electronics. Modern electronics can be affected by strong magnets. So keep the magnets away from phones, computers, tablets, etc!

3. These experiments are actually short-circuiting the battery. This means that the positive and negative terminals of the battery are hooked together without any sort of load. This can make the wire and the battery very hot. It is best to run the experiments in short bursts (30 seconds MAX) and then have a cool-down period. This also drains the batteries pretty quickly, so that is why your group is given a few batteries to use.

Let's grab our materials and learn about magnets!

Teaching tips

Welcome to the Magnetic Motion project! In this project, students will explore the interactions of magnets, electricity, and copper wires!

If you have completed the STEM Classic: Electromagnets project, that will help with some of the concepts in this project. Also, some of the materials from that project could be used in this project too!

Here is the list of needed materials: Link

2

What is a magnet?

10 min

In this step, you will learn the basics of magnets and magnetism.

Using the materials we have How can we identify the north and south poles of our magnets?

Now that we have learned about some magnetic properties, let's use these magnets in a simple circuit!

Teaching tips

In this step, students will learn the basics of magnets and magnetism. 

There is a video (Link) in the student-facing part of this step. You can either have the students watch the video independently, or, you could display it for the whole class to watch.

If you take that second option, around 4:10 there are some questions for understanding. You could stop the video and ask the questions to the class. The questions are:

How many types of magnets are there? (Answer: 3. Temporary, Permanent, and Electromagnets)

The area surrounding the magnet is called a magnetic ______ (Answer: Field)

True or False: The Earth's core has its own magnetic field (Answer: True)

What happens when two south poles of a magnet are near each other? (Answer: They repel each other)

An MRI is which type of magnet? (Answer: Electromagnet)

 

After the video, the students are then asked "How can we identify the north and south poles of our magnets?"

You can give the students some hints:

1. The north and south poles of the magnets are on the flat sides

2. They will need their pocket compass and one of the magnets (And markers or even a pencil)

Students should be able to line up the north and south poles using the compass. BUT, one error students often make is that when the magnet N is pointed toward the magnet, they often will label that side as the North. If you see students doing that, make sure to ask them "So, from the video, what happened when two south poles were put close to each other?" This might get them thinking that since they have the N of the compass pointed toward the magnet, the opposite pole is attracting it. Thus, the south side of the magnet is attracting the north side of the compass! 

3

Homopolar Motors

10 min

In this step, you will create a basic homopolar motor.

But first, we need to learn a little about current. When you touch a wire to the positive and negative leads of the battery, a circuit is created.

What happens when you touch one of your 8-inch wires to the positive and negative ends of a battery near your compass? Does anything happen?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Any time an electric current is present, a magnetic field is created! Then, when this electric field is created in an existing magnetic field (caused by the magnets on the bottom of the battery), then a force is created!

Watch the first two minutes of this video:

 

After watching the video, take two or three of your magnets, one of your 8-inch pieces of wire, and one AA battery, and try to make your own homopolar motor!

If you finish early, try to tweak your wire to make your homopolar motor go as fast as possible!

Once you have experimented with your homopolar motors, we will move on to make a tiny dancer!

Teaching tips

In this step, students will create a basic homopolar motor.

If you have completed the Electromagnets STEM Classic, it would be fun to ask the students about what happens when electricity moves through a wire. The answer is not only an electric field is created, but also a magnetic field!

If you have not completed the Electromagnets STEM Classic, students will touch a wire to both ends of a battery with the wire near one of the compasses. The wire will cause the compass to move!  You could ask students why this might happen. The answer is that any time there is current, a magnetic field is produced.

Some students may be successful in a matter of a few minutes while others may need more time. For those that finish early, see if they can tweak their design to be less wobbly or to get the fastest motor. 

I like the video that is shown in the student section (Link), but you only need the first 1:43. After that, it is just the same concept with different batteries.

4

Tiny Dancer

10 min

In this step, you will create a second homopolar motor in the form of a tiny dancer!

In the last step, you created a balanced homopolar motor. Now, can you make a second one with one of the legs bent up into the shape of a tiny dancer? 

STEAM Project: Tiny Dancers (A Homopolar Motor) Source https://babbledabbledo.com/steam-project-tiny-dancers-homopolar-motor/

How was this different from the first homopolar motor? Was this more or less difficult to do?

Now that we have explored homopolar motors, we are going to look at magnetic trains!

Teaching tips

In this step, students will create a second homopolar motor in the form of a tiny dancer!

There is a video of these dancers, but I don't think it adds much to the lesson (but here it is). 

Also, if you would like to assist your students in the making of the tiny dancer, you can print out a copy of this template for each student or group.

It is hard to resist, so here is Elton John's Tiny Dancer!

Again, if students finish early, you could encourage them to decorate their dancer and/or try to tweak them to be faster!

5

Electric Train

20 min

In this step, you will use a non-uniform electric field to create an electric train!

After watching the video, take the dowel and the 10-foot piece of wire and wind it. You want to wind it as tight as you can (see the picture,  right). This hammer's handle is a nice 5/8" dowel like you have. If you're working in a group, take turns winding the coil as it can be a tough process.

After you wind your coil, slide it off the end of the dowel. You should have a coil that is 4 or 5 inches long.

Now, assemble your "train." You will need 1 AAA battery and at least 2 magnets. Try putting your train in the coil. What happens?

Now, evenly stretch the coil so that it is about 9 inches long. Make sure the coils are fairly evenly spaced.

Experiment with the orientation and number of magnets until your train moves through the coil. What orientation worked best for the batteries and magnets (discuss in terms of the positive and negative sides of the battery and the north/south poles of the magnets)?

Later in the video, Physics Girl uses multiple batteries in a single "train." Can you make a train comprised of multiple batteries?

Using an Online Stopwatch, time your train as it goes through your coil. Create a table like this on paper. Add rows as needed.

Number of Batteries Number of Magnets in the front Number of Magnets in the back Number of batteries in the middle Time it took to pass through coil
         
         
         
         

After you have run some trials, do you have enough data to answer these questions?

--How does the number of batteries affect the time it takes to go through the coil?

--How does the number of magnets in the front affect the time it takes to go through the coil?

--How does the number of magnets in the back affect the time it takes to go through the coil?

--How does the number of magnets in the middle affect the time it takes to go through the coil?

 

Can you work with other groups to try to loop a train through multiple coils? 

Teaching tips

In this step, students will use a non-uniform electric field to create an electric train!

First off, we're going to watch a Physics Girl video about these electric trains. The magnets she is using are quite strong. Magnets like this are a few dollars each. If you're so inclined to use those, I recommend looking for a magnet that is graded N45 or higher. These ones can pinch a student very hard if they get their fingers in the way (ask me how I know), so that is why the weaker magnets are used in this project. The AAA battery trains will run more like the C battery train that is shown in the Physics Girl video. 

Also, in the material list, there is an optional straw. This is not a requirement, but I did cut a small cross-section to go over the button of the AAA battery. (pictured below).  So if students are having issues balancing the magnet on the button of the battery, show them that picture. They do not need a very large piece of straw. If it is too large, the magnet will not be physically touching the battery and the current will not flow. Too short and the spacer really won't work. The one that worked best for me was a 1.7mm long piece of straw. 

I am not telling the students how to orient their batteries or the polarity of their magnets. You can suggest to them to use their resources (the Physics Girl video, suggest having them start watching around the 3:30 mark). Also, here are some helpful images:

https://www.kjmagnetics.com/blog.asp?p=coiltrainhttps://www.kjmagnetics.com/blog.asp?p=coiltrain

Later, I suggest the students hold their tracks so their trains can go around a larger track. I did try soldering two 10-foot coil sections together. It did work, but it may also be just as effective to hold the coils together as Physics Girl does later in her videos. 

6

Reflection

10 min

In this step, you will reflect on the Magnetic Motion project. 

1. What parts of this project were easy? Which parts were more difficult?

2. Did you run into any problems while constructing your homopolar motor, Tiny Dancer, or electric train? Were you able to find a solution on your own? If not, where did you find help with a solution?

3. What did you learn about magnets?

4. What did you learn about motors?

5. From your experiments with the homopolar motor/Tiny Dancer, what made for the best motor/dancer?

6. From your experiment with the train and magnets, which combination (positive/negative battery terminals and North/South poles) allowed your train to move through the coil?

7. From your testing with the electric train, what combination of batteries and magnets made the fastest time going through the coil? Why do you think that was the case?

8. As a result of this project, please share one new idea or new question you may have come up with or encountered.

Teaching tips

In this step, students will reflect on the Magnetic Motion project.  

7

Optional Extension: Motor Mayhem

30 min

In this optional extension, you will create a DC motor and will change characteristics to try to get the motor to spin the fastest.

Start by watching this short video from the Bearded Science Guy.

Next, get your materials. For your first motor, use approximately 12 inches of magnet wire. Follow the instructions in the video except use magnets to hold the paper clips on the end. I also made the paper into a stand that held the motor over to the side of the battery. 

Once you have a working motor, how can you make it go faster? Could you increase the number of coils? What about the thickness of the magnet wire (your teacher may or may not have other magnet wires)? What about the number of magnets and the distance between the coil and the magnet(s)? Could you increase the voltage by adding more magnets?

Since the motors are spinning very quickly, how can we count the number of turns every second (RPS) or minute (RPM)?

After trying out a few different combinations, what factors did you find helped make your motor run faster?

Teaching tips

In this optional extension, students will create a DC motor and will change characteristics to try to get the motor to spin the fastest.

Note, that some of these motors will move VERY quickly. I have found that most newer phones have cameras with a slow-motion setting. This could aid in counting the number of rotations per minute or rotations per second (if you're okay with students using their own devices).

In the materials, I mention magnet wire. If you have done the electromagnet project, you likely have three different sizes of magnet wire hanging around. If not, a single roll of 20 gauge wire will work fine for this, we would just need to change the number of coils rather than the gauge of the wire. If you buy one of those spools linked in the materials list, that should have about 80 feet of wire. This means there is enough for 10 feet per group. 

Materials

  • Neodymium magnets (12x3 mm) — 10 per group
  • Copper wire, 8 in lengths — 6 per group
  • Copper wire, 10 ft length — 1 per group
  • Wooden dowel (5/8 x 12 in) — 1 per group
  • Pocket button compass — 1 per group
  • Needle nose pliers — 1 per group
  • AA batteries — 5 per group
  • AAA batteries — 5 per group
  • Markers
  • Scissors
  • Straws
  • Paper and tape (to decorate the tiny dancer)
  • Magnet wire
  • Paper clips (all metal) — 16 per classroom
  • 200 grit sandpaper — 1 per classroom

Ready to bring this lesson to your classroom?

Sign up to save this lesson, order supplies, and track student progress.